Wednesday, August 26, 2009

Pirate Cake

Amy asked me to post this here (disaster and all) so here goes!!

Today was my son's 5th birthday, and he wanted a pirate-themed birthday party with his friends. We found this pirate cake on-line. After watching the accompanying video, we thought it looked pretty easy! Here's the recipe, and then I'll give my 2 cents on it.


Ingredients
2 boxes (18.25 ounces each) cake mix (we used chocolate)
2 cans (16 ounces each) milk-chocolate buttercream frosting
1 can (12 ounces) whipped vanilla frosting, divided
Blue, red, and yellow icing colors
3 black licorice twists
1 small bag of square-grid pretzels, such as Snaps
1 each round cookie and pretzel rod
2 chopsticks
Paper for sails


Directions
1. Bake two 9 x 13-inch cakes according to directions. Let cakes cool completely. Place one cake on serving platter. Cut a 2-1/2-inch slice from one short end of the second cake. Cut the remaining piece of the second cake in half horizontally.
2. Using chocolate frosting, attach small cake piece to the end of the large cake on the platter (see photo above). Using chocolate frosting, attach 2 large pieces of cake on top of each end of base cake. With a serrated knife, cut step from top layer of back end of ship to create third level of ship (see photo). With cake layers assembled, cut boat shape using our template below as a guide. Frost entire cake with chocolate buttercream. Using a small fork, gently score the entire cake with wavy lines to simulate wood.
3. Divide vanilla frosting among 3 bowls. Tint one blue, one red, and one yellow. Place blue frosting in a piping bag fitted with a ribbon tip, and place red and yellow frostings in bags fitted with plain tips. Pipe blue trim around entire upper edge of ship, then pipe red frosting underneath the blue. Cut licorice into 20 lengths. Insert licorice pieces into sides of ship for cannons. Pipe half circles of yellow frosting over cannons. Pipe yellow windows across the stern and around the back of ship. Pipe yellow curlicue designs on bow of ship and decorate with red dots of frosting.
4. Using a serrated knife, gently cut pretzels in half. Place pretzels around bow and stern for railings. Using chocolate frosting, pipe the captain's wheel on the round cookie. Attach wheel to pretzel rod with chocolate frosting and insert in cake near bow.
5. To make sails, download our template at parents.com/pirateship. Print them, then cut out; use chopsticks to mount them on cake.
My discoveries/hints:
Building the cake was very, very easy. Took me no time at all, and I didn't use the pattern provided. The frosting gave me HECK though (which really, really surprised me)! I tried doing a crumb layer, but to no avail. Everything was just too moist so I got crumbs in many spots, which really bugs me. I also couldn't get the frosting to adhere to the cake in some places. I was so frustrated! You can't see it in this picture, but the back corner of the ship actually collapsed completely.
I posted this on my crafty kids blog and someone wrote that if you freeze it first, it helps with the crumbs. I'll have to try that next time. Also, I was worried the pretzels and licorice were going to fall down because of the moistness (they didn't), but I think next time, I will add them the next morning after the cake and frosting have had time to settle a bit.
I also got that store-bought colored frosting that comes all ready prepped in the tube. I figured it'd be easier since there were three colors. Not a big fan. It was hard and didn't stick to the chocolate frosting well. I couldn't keep the lines straight and they kept breaking. So frustrating! I was hoping to add my son's name to the front and some more fun decorations, but...
Despite all of this though, I would definitely make it again. It took me a little over an hour, but I think with that freezer hint, I may have more success next time! My son LOVED it, and so did the other kids and parents! What more can you ask for?!
I need to give credit where it's due. Here's the link on parents.com: http://www.parents.com/recipe/frosting/pirate-cake/
(sorry about the formatting. can't get it to work so everything is mushing together!)

No comments: